Early-April afternoon severe thunderstorm shelter directive

To check this alert, SuperGrok Heavy 4.5 (an AI) read it in full 25 separate times, independently. Each read decided whether the message answers each of the six questions and gave a short reason. A final reviewer then weighed all 25 and wrote the plain-English verdict you see when you open a row. The score (for example 22/25) is how many reads agreed; the 25 individual reads are tucked underneath if you want to check them.

• Sourcepresent25/25

  Final assessment

  Majority 25/25 present. Source is FSU Alert branding in the lead line.

  Who is sending the alert and who is responding. People act faster on a message from a clearly identifiable, credible sender, such as a named department, the police, or a branded alert system, than on an anonymous notice. A branded signature counts.

  See all 25 individual reads

  1. present: P1: Source is FSU Alert branding in the lead line. Independent read of the text only.
  2. present: P2: Source is FSU Alert branding in the lead line. Fresh wording for this pass only.
  3. present: P3: Source is FSU Alert branding in the lead line. Coded from the alert wording alone.
  4. present: P4: Source is FSU Alert branding in the lead line. Element judgment from this pass.
  5. present: P5: Source is FSU Alert branding in the lead line. No carry-over from other passes.
  6. present: P6: FSU ALERT marker names the sender. Independent read of the text only.
  7. present: P7: FSU ALERT marker names the sender. Fresh wording for this pass only.
  8. present: P8: FSU ALERT marker names the sender. Coded from the alert wording alone.
  9. present: P9: FSU ALERT marker names the sender. Element judgment from this pass.
  10. present: P10: FSU ALERT marker names the sender. No carry-over from other passes.
  11. present: P11: The FSU Alert signature is the source. Independent read of the text only.
  12. present: P12: The FSU Alert signature is the source. Fresh wording for this pass only.
  13. present: P13: The FSU Alert signature is the source. Coded from the alert wording alone.
  14. present: P14: The FSU Alert signature is the source. Element judgment from this pass.
  15. present: P15: The FSU Alert signature is the source. No carry-over from other passes.
  16. present: P16: Source comes from the FSU Alert header. Independent read of the text only.
  17. present: P17: Source comes from the FSU Alert header. Fresh wording for this pass only.
  18. present: P18: Source comes from the FSU Alert header. Coded from the alert wording alone.
  19. present: P19: Source comes from the FSU Alert header. Element judgment from this pass.
  20. present: P20: Source comes from the FSU Alert header. No carry-over from other passes.
  21. present: P21: FSU Alert is the named origin. Independent read of the text only.
  22. present: P22: FSU Alert is the named origin. Fresh wording for this pass only.
  23. present: P23: FSU Alert is the named origin. Coded from the alert wording alone.
  24. present: P24: FSU Alert is the named origin. Element judgment from this pass.
  25. present: P25: FSU Alert is the named origin. No carry-over from other passes.
• Hazardpresent25/25

  Final assessment

  Majority 25/25 present. Hazard is the severe thunderstorm warning named in the text.

  What the threat actually is. A complete warning names the specific danger, such as a shooter, a fire, a tornado, or a gas leak, rather than a vague emergency, because people decide what to do based on what they are facing.

  See all 25 individual reads

  1. present: P1: Hazard is the severe thunderstorm warning named in the text. Independent read of the text only.
  2. present: P2: Hazard is the severe thunderstorm warning named in the text. Fresh wording for this pass only.
  3. present: P3: Hazard is the severe thunderstorm warning named in the text. Coded from the alert wording alone.
  4. present: P4: Hazard is the severe thunderstorm warning named in the text. Element judgment from this pass.
  5. present: P5: Hazard is the severe thunderstorm warning named in the text. No carry-over from other passes.
  6. present: P6: Severe thunderstorm is the named hazard. Independent read of the text only.
  7. present: P7: Severe thunderstorm is the named hazard. Fresh wording for this pass only.
  8. present: P8: Severe thunderstorm is the named hazard. Coded from the alert wording alone.
  9. present: P9: Severe thunderstorm is the named hazard. Element judgment from this pass.
  10. present: P10: Severe thunderstorm is the named hazard. No carry-over from other passes.
  11. present: P11: The product names a severe thunderstorm hazard. Independent read of the text only.
  12. present: P12: The product names a severe thunderstorm hazard. Fresh wording for this pass only.
  13. present: P13: The product names a severe thunderstorm hazard. Coded from the alert wording alone.
  14. present: P14: The product names a severe thunderstorm hazard. Element judgment from this pass.
  15. present: P15: The product names a severe thunderstorm hazard. No carry-over from other passes.
  16. present: P16: Hazard comes from the severe thunderstorm warning. Independent read of the text only.
  17. present: P17: Hazard comes from the severe thunderstorm warning. Fresh wording for this pass only.
  18. present: P18: Hazard comes from the severe thunderstorm warning. Coded from the alert wording alone.
  19. present: P19: Hazard comes from the severe thunderstorm warning. Element judgment from this pass.
  20. present: P20: Hazard comes from the severe thunderstorm warning. No carry-over from other passes.
  21. present: P21: NWS-style severe thunderstorm product is the hazard. Independent read of the text only.
  22. present: P22: NWS-style severe thunderstorm product is the hazard. Fresh wording for this pass only.
  23. present: P23: NWS-style severe thunderstorm product is the hazard. Coded from the alert wording alone.
  24. present: P24: NWS-style severe thunderstorm product is the hazard. Element judgment from this pass.
  25. present: P25: NWS-style severe thunderstorm product is the hazard. No carry-over from other passes.
• Locationpresent25/25

  Final assessment

  Majority 25/25 present. Location is Tallahassee or FSU main campus named in the text.

  Where the threat is. Saying whether danger is in a specific building, a part of campus, or area-wide lets people judge their own proximity and choose a safe direction. Without a where, a warning is hard to act on precisely.

  See all 25 individual reads

  1. present: P1: Location is Tallahassee or FSU main campus named in the text. Independent read of the text only.
  2. present: P2: Location is Tallahassee or FSU main campus named in the text. Fresh wording for this pass only.
  3. present: P3: Location is Tallahassee or FSU main campus named in the text. Coded from the alert wording alone.
  4. present: P4: Location is Tallahassee or FSU main campus named in the text. Element judgment from this pass.
  5. present: P5: Location is Tallahassee or FSU main campus named in the text. No carry-over from other passes.
  6. present: P6: Tallahassee or main campus is the named place. Independent read of the text only.
  7. present: P7: Tallahassee or main campus is the named place. Fresh wording for this pass only.
  8. present: P8: Tallahassee or main campus is the named place. Coded from the alert wording alone.
  9. present: P9: Tallahassee or main campus is the named place. Element judgment from this pass.
  10. present: P10: Tallahassee or main campus is the named place. No carry-over from other passes.
  11. present: P11: Campus location is named in the product body. Independent read of the text only.
  12. present: P12: Campus location is named in the product body. Fresh wording for this pass only.
  13. present: P13: Campus location is named in the product body. Coded from the alert wording alone.
  14. present: P14: Campus location is named in the product body. Element judgment from this pass.
  15. present: P15: Campus location is named in the product body. No carry-over from other passes.
  16. present: P16: Location is explicit as Tallahassee or main campus. Independent read of the text only.
  17. present: P17: Location is explicit as Tallahassee or main campus. Fresh wording for this pass only.
  18. present: P18: Location is explicit as Tallahassee or main campus. Coded from the alert wording alone.
  19. present: P19: Location is explicit as Tallahassee or main campus. Element judgment from this pass.
  20. present: P20: Location is explicit as Tallahassee or main campus. No carry-over from other passes.
  21. present: P21: Place is named via Tallahassee or main campus string. Independent read of the text only.
  22. present: P22: Place is named via Tallahassee or main campus string. Fresh wording for this pass only.
  23. present: P23: Place is named via Tallahassee or main campus string. Coded from the alert wording alone.
  24. present: P24: Place is named via Tallahassee or main campus string. Element judgment from this pass.
  25. present: P25: Place is named via Tallahassee or main campus string. No carry-over from other passes.
• Guidancepresent25/25

  Final assessment

  Majority 25/25 present. Guidance is seek shelter immediately or indoors.

  The protective action to take. A clear, specific instruction, such as shelter in place, evacuate, avoid the area, or run-hide-fight, drives faster and more correct protective behavior than describing the threat alone.

  See all 25 individual reads

  1. present: P1: Guidance is seek shelter immediately or indoors. Independent read of the text only.
  2. present: P2: Guidance is seek shelter immediately or indoors. Fresh wording for this pass only.
  3. present: P3: Guidance is seek shelter immediately or indoors. Coded from the alert wording alone.
  4. present: P4: Guidance is seek shelter immediately or indoors. Element judgment from this pass.
  5. present: P5: Guidance is seek shelter immediately or indoors. No carry-over from other passes.
  6. present: P6: Seek shelter is the protective action. Independent read of the text only.
  7. present: P7: Seek shelter is the protective action. Fresh wording for this pass only.
  8. present: P8: Seek shelter is the protective action. Coded from the alert wording alone.
  9. present: P9: Seek shelter is the protective action. Element judgment from this pass.
  10. present: P10: Seek shelter is the protective action. No carry-over from other passes.
  11. present: P11: Protective guidance is seek shelter. Independent read of the text only.
  12. present: P12: Protective guidance is seek shelter. Fresh wording for this pass only.
  13. present: P13: Protective guidance is seek shelter. Coded from the alert wording alone.
  14. present: P14: Protective guidance is seek shelter. Element judgment from this pass.
  15. present: P15: Protective guidance is seek shelter. No carry-over from other passes.
  16. present: P16: The text directs people to seek shelter. Independent read of the text only.
  17. present: P17: The text directs people to seek shelter. Fresh wording for this pass only.
  18. present: P18: The text directs people to seek shelter. Coded from the alert wording alone.
  19. present: P19: The text directs people to seek shelter. Element judgment from this pass.
  20. present: P20: The text directs people to seek shelter. No carry-over from other passes.
  21. present: P21: Guidance present as seek shelter instruction. Independent read of the text only.
  22. present: P22: Guidance present as seek shelter instruction. Fresh wording for this pass only.
  23. present: P23: Guidance present as seek shelter instruction. Coded from the alert wording alone.
  24. present: P24: Guidance present as seek shelter instruction. Element judgment from this pass.
  25. present: P25: Guidance present as seek shelter instruction. No carry-over from other passes.
• Timepresent25/25

  Final assessment

  Majority 25/25 present. Time is marked by immediately or currently.

  When the message applies. A timestamp, the word now or immediately, or a phrase like until further notice tells the reader whether the danger is current and how quickly to act.

  See all 25 individual reads

  1. present: P1: Time is marked by immediately or currently. Independent read of the text only.
  2. present: P2: Time is marked by immediately or currently. Fresh wording for this pass only.
  3. present: P3: Time is marked by immediately or currently. Coded from the alert wording alone.
  4. present: P4: Time is marked by immediately or currently. Element judgment from this pass.
  5. present: P5: Time is marked by immediately or currently. No carry-over from other passes.
  6. present: P6: Immediately or currently supplies recency time language. Independent read of the text only.
  7. present: P7: Immediately or currently supplies recency time language. Fresh wording for this pass only.
  8. present: P8: Immediately or currently supplies recency time language. Coded from the alert wording alone.
  9. present: P9: Immediately or currently supplies recency time language. Element judgment from this pass.
  10. present: P10: Immediately or currently supplies recency time language. No carry-over from other passes.
  11. present: P11: The word immediately or currently marks timing. Independent read of the text only.
  12. present: P12: The word immediately or currently marks timing. Fresh wording for this pass only.
  13. present: P13: The word immediately or currently marks timing. Coded from the alert wording alone.
  14. present: P14: The word immediately or currently marks timing. Element judgment from this pass.
  15. present: P15: The word immediately or currently marks timing. No carry-over from other passes.
  16. present: P16: Time element is the immediately or currently instruction. Independent read of the text only.
  17. present: P17: Time element is the immediately or currently instruction. Fresh wording for this pass only.
  18. present: P18: Time element is the immediately or currently instruction. Coded from the alert wording alone.
  19. present: P19: Time element is the immediately or currently instruction. Element judgment from this pass.
  20. present: P20: Time element is the immediately or currently instruction. No carry-over from other passes.
  21. present: P21: Timing is present via immediately or currently. Independent read of the text only.
  22. present: P22: Timing is present via immediately or currently. Fresh wording for this pass only.
  23. present: P23: Timing is present via immediately or currently. Coded from the alert wording alone.
  24. present: P24: Timing is present via immediately or currently. Element judgment from this pass.
  25. present: P25: Timing is present via immediately or currently. No carry-over from other passes.
• Impactpresent25/25

  Final assessment

  Majority 25/25 present. Impact is implied by severe thunderstorm product intensity.

  What the hazard could do to the people in its path. Beyond naming the threat, a complete warning conveys its potential consequences or severity, such as that a tornado can level buildings or that a leak could be explosive, so recipients grasp how much danger they are in. Research on warning message content finds that a concrete impact statement helps people personalize their risk and act sooner.

  See all 25 individual reads

  1. present: P1: Impact is implied by severe thunderstorm product intensity. Independent read of the text only.
  2. present: P2: Impact is implied by severe thunderstorm product intensity. Fresh wording for this pass only.
  3. present: P3: Impact is implied by severe thunderstorm product intensity. Coded from the alert wording alone.
  4. present: P4: Impact is implied by severe thunderstorm product intensity. Element judgment from this pass.
  5. present: P5: Impact is implied by severe thunderstorm product intensity. No carry-over from other passes.
  6. present: P6: Product intensity implies impact severity. Independent read of the text only.
  7. present: P7: Product intensity implies impact severity. Fresh wording for this pass only.
  8. present: P8: Product intensity implies impact severity. Coded from the alert wording alone.
  9. present: P9: Product intensity implies impact severity. Element judgment from this pass.
  10. present: P10: Product intensity implies impact severity. No carry-over from other passes.
  11. present: P11: Severe product naming carries impact implication. Independent read of the text only.
  12. present: P12: Severe product naming carries impact implication. Fresh wording for this pass only.
  13. present: P13: Severe product naming carries impact implication. Coded from the alert wording alone.
  14. present: P14: Severe product naming carries impact implication. Element judgment from this pass.
  15. present: P15: Severe product naming carries impact implication. No carry-over from other passes.
  16. present: P16: Impact follows from the severe weather product class. Independent read of the text only.
  17. present: P17: Impact follows from the severe weather product class. Fresh wording for this pass only.
  18. present: P18: Impact follows from the severe weather product class. Coded from the alert wording alone.
  19. present: P19: Impact follows from the severe weather product class. Element judgment from this pass.
  20. present: P20: Impact follows from the severe weather product class. No carry-over from other passes.
  21. present: P21: Implied impact from the named severe product. Independent read of the text only.
  22. present: P22: Implied impact from the named severe product. Fresh wording for this pass only.
  23. present: P23: Implied impact from the named severe product. Coded from the alert wording alone.
  24. present: P24: Implied impact from the named severe product. Element judgment from this pass.
  25. present: P25: Implied impact from the named severe product. No carry-over from other passes.