A coastal storm notice tells people to stay back from the surf

To check this alert, SuperGrok Heavy 4.5 (an AI) read it in full 25 separate times, independently. Each read decided whether the message answers each of the six questions and gave a short reason. A final reviewer then weighed all 25 and wrote the plain-English verdict you see when you open a row. The score (for example 22/25) is how many reads agreed; the 25 individual reads are tucked underneath if you want to check them.

• Sourceabsent7/25

  Final assessment

  7 of 25 passes marked Source present and 18 absent. The comet judge finds no sender, because Dear UNE Community names the audience and emergency personnel are not identified as the issuer.

  Who is sending the alert and who is responding. People act faster on a message from a clearly identifiable, credible sender, such as a named department, the police, or a branded alert system, than on an anonymous notice. A branded signature counts.

  See all 25 individual reads

  1. absent: The comet judge finds no sender, because Dear UNE Community names the audience and emergency personnel are not identified as the issuer.
  2. absent: The word draco marks source absent because Dear UNE Community names the audience and no office, signature, or agency is the sender.
  3. absent: The salutation Dear UNE Community names the audience, not a sender or agency, so equinox finds source absent.
  4. absent: The flare of this greeting addresses the UNE Community but never names a sender, branded signature, or issuing authority.
  5. absent: The galaxy of senders is missing because Dear UNE Community names the audience, not a branded signature, university issuer, or agency.
  6. absent: This halo review finds no sender, since Dear UNE Community only names the audience and no office, police, or branded signature is given.
  7. present: Dear UNE Community names the university itself, so the issuing institution is identified in this ion of the alert.
  8. present: The opening "Dear UNE Community" names the university itself, so jupiter counts UNE as the identified sender.
  9. present: The opening "Dear UNE Community" names the university itself, so kepler marks the sender as present.
  10. absent: Under a lunar standard, the greeting Dear UNE Community names the audience while we and emergency personnel never identify the sender.
  11. absent: The meteor reading finds no issuing authority, since "Dear UNE Community" names the audience rather than a branded signature, university sender, or agency.
  12. absent: The nebula reading finds source absent because "Dear UNE Community" names the audience, not a branded sender, university issuer, or named agency.
  13. present: Opening with "Dear UNE Community" names the university itself, which puts UNE in the orbit of who is addressing recipients.
  14. absent: The salutation addresses the UNE Community but never names a sender, branded alert signature, or issuing agency, so pulsar finds no source.
  15. absent: A quasar check finds no issuing authority, since Dear UNE Community only names the audience and emergency personnel are not the stated sender.
  16. absent: The greeting addresses UNE Community but never names a sender or agency, so rigel codes source absent.
  17. absent: The solar message never names a sender or issuing office, because Dear UNE Community only addresses recipients and emergency personnel are not identified as the source.
  18. absent: The titan reading finds no issuing authority, because Dear UNE Community names the audience and we is unnamed, with no branded sender tag.
  19. present: The greeting "Dear UNE Community" names the university itself, so the sender is identified in the umbra of this message.
  20. absent: Vega finds no sender because Dear UNE Community names only the audience, while we and emergency personnel never identify who issued the alert.
  21. absent: The greeting Dear UNE Community addresses recipients and never names a waxing sender, branded signature, or issuing agency.
  22. absent: The greeting Dear UNE Community names the audience rather than a sender, and xenon finds no branded signature or named issuing agency.
  23. absent: The zodiac reading finds no sender: "Dear UNE Community" names the audience, and unnamed "we" never identifies an issuing office or branded alert signature.
  24. present: The greeting "Dear UNE Community" names the university itself, which aurora counts as identifying the sender.
  25. present: The message names UNE in the salutation Dear UNE Community and speaks as that university, which identifies the corona source.
• Hazardpresent25/25

  Final assessment

  25 of 25 passes marked Hazard present and 0 absent. The comet text names a specific storm hazard with high surf, powerful waves, strong currents, and slippery surfaces.

  What the threat actually is. A complete warning names the specific danger, such as a shooter, a fire, a tornado, or a gas leak, rather than a vague emergency, because people decide what to do based on what they are facing.

  See all 25 individual reads

  1. present: The comet text names a specific storm hazard with high surf, powerful waves, strong currents, and slippery surfaces.
  2. present: The word draco marks hazard present because the text names a storm with high surf, powerful waves, strong currents, and slippery surfaces.
  3. present: It specifies a storm producing high surf, powerful waves, strong currents, and slippery surfaces, so equinox finds the hazard present.
  4. present: The flare names a storm with high surf, powerful waves, and strong currents, which is a specific hazard.
  5. present: The galaxy of threats is specific: a storm expected to bring high surf, powerful waves, strong currents, and slippery surfaces.
  6. present: This halo review finds a specific hazard, because the text names a storm with high surf, powerful waves, strong currents, and slippery surfaces.
  7. present: The text names a storm plus high surf, powerful waves, and strong currents, a specific hazard in this ion.
  8. present: It specifies a storm producing high surf, powerful waves, strong currents, and slippery surfaces, a concrete threat jupiter accepts.
  9. present: It names a storm with high surf, powerful waves, strong currents, and slippery surfaces, which kepler treats as a specific hazard.
  10. present: Under a lunar standard, the text names the specific hazard as a storm producing high surf, powerful waves, and strong currents.
  11. present: The meteor reading finds a specific hazard because the text names a "storm" with "high surf", "powerful waves", and "strong currents".
  12. present: The nebula reading finds hazard present because the text specifies a storm producing high surf, powerful waves, strong currents, and slippery surfaces.
  13. present: The message specifies a "storm" with "high surf", "powerful waves", and "strong currents", so the hazard sits in orbit and is not a generic incident.
  14. present: The text names a storm that will bring high surf, powerful waves, strong currents, and slippery surfaces, which pulsar treats as a specific hazard.
  15. present: A quasar check finds a specific threat, since the text names a storm with high surf, powerful waves, strong currents, and slippery surfaces.
  16. present: A storm with high surf, powerful waves, and strong currents is named, so rigel codes the hazard present.
  17. present: The solar text specifies a storm with high surf, larger and more powerful waves, strong currents, and slippery surfaces.
  18. present: The titan reading finds a specific hazard, because the text names a storm with high surf, powerful waves, strong currents, and slippery surfaces.
  19. present: It specifies a storm producing high surf, powerful waves, strong currents, and slippery surfaces, which gives the hazard a clear umbra.
  20. present: Vega finds a specific hazard because the text names a storm with high surf, larger waves, strong currents, and slippery surfaces.
  21. present: It names a storm plus high surf, powerful waves, strong currents, and slippery surfaces, a waxing specific threat rather than a generic emergency.
  22. present: A xenon reading finds a specific hazard because the text names a storm with high surf, powerful waves, and strong currents.
  23. present: The zodiac reading finds a specific hazard in "storm" plus "high surf", "powerful waves", "strong currents", and "slippery surfaces".
  24. present: It specifies a storm producing high surf, powerful waves, strong currents, and slippery surfaces, so aurora codes Hazard present.
  25. present: It specifies a storm producing high surf, powerful waves, strong currents, and slippery surfaces, a concrete corona hazard.
• Locationpresent25/25

  Final assessment

  25 of 25 passes marked Location present and 0 absent. The comet location is the coast and coastline, including rocks, jetties, and our area.

  Where the threat is. Saying whether danger is in a specific building, a part of campus, or area-wide lets people judge their own proximity and choose a safe direction. Without a where, a warning is hard to act on precisely.

  See all 25 individual reads

  1. present: The comet location is the coast and coastline, including rocks, jetties, and our area.
  2. present: The word draco marks location present because the alert points to our area, the coast, the coastline, and coastal rocks.
  3. present: It places the risk in our area, around the coast, and near the coastline, so equinox finds location present.
  4. present: The flare places the risk around the coast, the coastline, rocks, jetties, and the water's edge.
  5. present: The galaxy of places includes our area, the coast, the coastline, rocks, jetties, and the water's edge.
  6. present: This halo review finds a location, because the message refers to our area, the coast, the coastline, rocks, and jetties.
  7. present: It locates the threat around the coast, the coastline, and the area, which is enough place detail in this ion.
  8. present: It places the risk around the coast, the coastline, and our area, locations jupiter treats as sufficient.
  9. present: It locates the threat in "our area", "around the coast", and "near the coastline", so kepler counts location as present.
  10. present: Under a lunar standard, location is given as our area, the coast, the coastline, rocks, and jetties.
  11. present: The meteor reading finds a place because the text says "our area", "around the coast", and "near the coastline".
  12. present: The nebula reading finds location present because it refers to "our area", the coast, the coastline, rocks, and jetties.
  13. present: It locates the risk "around the coast", "near the coastline", and in "our area", which is enough place detail for the orbit of where.
  14. present: It locates the risk around the coast, the coastline, rocks, jetties, and the water's edge, which pulsar accepts as a place.
  15. present: A quasar check finds location, since the text refers to the coast, the coastline, rocks and jetties, and our area.
  16. present: Risk is placed around the coast, the coastline, and the water's edge, so rigel codes location present.
  17. present: The solar warning locates the risk around the coast, the coastline, rocks, jetties, and the water in our area.
  18. present: The titan reading finds a place, because the text locates risk around the coast, the coastline, and the water's edge in our area.
  19. present: The warning places the risk in "our area," along the coast, the coastline, and coastal rocks, so location has an umbra.
  20. present: Vega finds location because the message points to our area, the coast, the coastline, rocks, and jetties.
  21. present: Phrases such as our area, around the coast, and near the coastline say where the risk is, a waxing location even without a campus building.
  22. present: Location is present for xenon in our area, around the coast, and near the coastline.
  23. present: The zodiac reading finds location in "our area", "around the coast", "near the coastline", and "coastal rocks".
  24. present: It locates the risk around the coast and near the coastline in our area, so aurora codes Location present.
  25. present: It locates the risk around the coast, the coastline, and our area, so a corona place is given.
• Guidancepresent25/25

  Final assessment

  25 of 25 passes marked Guidance present and 0 absent. The comet guidance tells people to stay well back, avoid wet rocks, not enter the water, and stay away.

  The protective action to take. A clear, specific instruction, such as shelter in place, evacuate, avoid the area, or run-hide-fight, drives faster and more correct protective behavior than describing the threat alone.

  See all 25 individual reads

  1. present: The comet guidance tells people to stay well back, avoid wet rocks, not enter the water, and stay away.
  2. present: The word draco marks guidance present because people are told to stay back, avoid wet rocks, skip rough water, and stay away until conditions improve.
  3. present: It tells people to stay well back, avoid wet rocks, not enter rough water, and stay away, so equinox finds guidance present.
  4. present: The flare instructs people to stay well back from the water, not enter it, and stay away from coastal rocks.
  5. present: The galaxy of instructions says to use extra caution, stay back, avoid wet rocks, not enter rough water, follow posted warnings, and stay away.
  6. present: This halo review finds protective guidance, because people are told to stay back, avoid wet rocks, stay out of rough water, and follow posted warnings.
  7. present: Recipients are told to stay back, avoid wet rocks, not enter rough water, and stay away, which is guidance in this ion.
  8. present: Recipients are told to stay back, avoid wet rocks, and not enter rough water, protective steps jupiter codes as guidance.
  9. present: It tells people to stay back, avoid wet rocks, not enter the water, and stay away, which kepler codes as guidance.
  10. present: Under a lunar standard, recipients are told to stay back from the water, not enter it, and stay away from coastal rocks.
  11. present: The meteor reading finds protective guidance in "Stay well back from the water's edge", "Do not enter the water", and "stay away from the water".
  12. present: The nebula reading finds guidance present because it tells people to use caution, stay back, avoid wet rocks, not enter the water, and stay away.
  13. present: It tells recipients to "stay well back", "do not enter the water", and "stay away" from rocks, so those protective actions sit in the guidance orbit.
  14. present: It tells people to stay back, avoid wet rocks, not enter the water, and stay away until conditions improve, which pulsar counts as guidance.
  15. present: A quasar check finds protective action, since recipients are told to stay back, avoid wet rocks, not enter the water, and stay away until conditions improve.
  16. present: People are told to stay back, avoid wet rocks, and not enter rough water, so rigel codes guidance present.
  17. present: The solar instructions say to use extra caution, stay well back, avoid wet rocks, not enter rough water, and follow posted warnings.
  18. present: The titan reading finds protective instructions, including stay well back, do not enter the water, and stay away from coastal rocks.
  19. present: People are told to use caution, stay back from the water, avoid wet rocks, not enter rough water, and stay away, the umbra of guidance.
  20. present: Vega finds guidance because people are told to stay back, avoid wet rocks, not enter rough water, and follow posted warnings.
  21. present: It tells people to use caution, stay back from the water, avoid wet rocks, not enter rough water, and stay away until conditions improve, all waxing protective actions.
  22. present: Protective actions are present for xenon, including stay well back, do not enter the water, and stay away from coastal rocks.
  23. present: The zodiac reading finds protective instructions: "Stay well back", "Do not enter the water", "avoid climbing", and "stay away from the water".
  24. present: It tells people to stay well back, not enter the water, and stay away from coastal rocks, so aurora codes Guidance present.
  25. present: Recipients are told to stay back from the water, avoid wet rocks, not enter the water, and stay away, which is corona guidance.
• Timepresent25/25

  Final assessment

  25 of 25 passes marked Time present and 0 absent. The comet time cue is this weekend, which says when the storm and the caution apply.

  When the message applies. A timestamp, the word now or immediately, or a phrase like until further notice tells the reader whether the danger is current and how quickly to act.

  See all 25 individual reads

  1. present: The comet time cue is this weekend, which says when the storm and the caution apply.
  2. present: The word draco marks time present because this weekend states when the storm and coastal caution apply.
  3. present: This weekend and until conditions improve state when to act, so equinox finds time present.
  4. present: The flare says the storm is expected this weekend and to stay away until conditions improve.
  5. present: The galaxy of timing is this weekend, which states when the storm and the caution apply.
  6. present: This halo review finds a time cue, because the storm is tied to this weekend and people should stay away until conditions improve.
  7. present: The phrase this weekend states when the storm is expected, a clear time cue in this ion of the text.
  8. present: "This weekend" and "until conditions improve" state when the risk applies, so jupiter marks time present.
  9. present: "This weekend" and "until conditions improve" say when the threat applies, so kepler marks time as present.
  10. present: Under a lunar standard, this weekend states when the storm and the coastal caution apply.
  11. present: The meteor reading finds timing in "this weekend" and "until conditions improve", while "immediately around you" is spatial rather than a clock time.
  12. present: The nebula reading finds time present because the warning is for "this weekend" and lasts "until conditions improve".
  13. present: "This weekend" and "until conditions improve" state when the caution applies, giving the alert a clear time orbit.
  14. present: The phrase this weekend states when the storm is expected, which pulsar counts as a time cue.
  15. present: A quasar check finds timing, since the storm and the coastal advice are tied to this weekend and last until conditions improve.
  16. present: This weekend states when the storm is expected, so rigel codes time present.
  17. present: The solar alert ties the storm to this weekend and tells people to stay away until conditions improve.
  18. present: The titan reading finds a time cue, because the storm is tied to this weekend and advice lasts until conditions improve.
  19. present: "This weekend" and "until conditions improve" say when the danger applies, so time is present in the umbra of the wording.
  20. present: Vega finds time because the storm is expected this weekend and the caution lasts until conditions improve.
  21. present: The phrase this weekend states when the storm is expected, a waxing time cue, whereas immediately around you is spatial rather than temporal.
  22. present: The repeated phrase this weekend gives xenon a clear time window for the expected storm.
  23. present: The zodiac reading finds timing in "this weekend" and "until conditions improve", which state when the caution applies.
  24. present: "This weekend" states when the storm is expected to affect the area, so aurora codes Time present.
  25. present: The phrases this weekend and until conditions improve tell when the caution applies, a corona time marker.
• Impactpresent25/25

  Final assessment

  25 of 25 passes marked Impact present and 0 absent. The comet impact is severity: potentially hazardous conditions and water that may be unsafe, not just the storm name.

  What the hazard could do to the people in its path. Beyond naming the threat, a complete warning conveys its potential consequences or severity, such as that a tornado can level buildings or that a leak could be explosive, so recipients grasp how much danger they are in. Research on warning message content finds that a concrete impact statement helps people personalize their risk and act sooner.

  See all 25 individual reads

  1. present: The comet impact is severity: potentially hazardous conditions and water that may be unsafe, not just the storm name.
  2. present: The word draco marks impact present because conditions are called potentially hazardous and the water is described as unsafe.
  3. present: Potentially hazardous conditions and unsafe water state severity and possible harm, so equinox finds impact present.
  4. present: The flare calls the surf potentially hazardous and the water unsafe, stating severity beyond merely naming a storm.
  5. present: The galaxy of severity appears in potentially hazardous conditions and water described as unsafe, not only the storm's name.
  6. present: This halo review finds stated severity, because the message warns of potentially hazardous conditions and says the water can be unsafe.
  7. present: Potentially hazardous conditions and unsafe water state severity beyond the hazard name alone in this ion.
  8. present: "Potentially hazardous conditions" and "unsafe" convey severity beyond naming the storm, which jupiter scores as impact.
  9. present: "Potentially hazardous conditions" and "unsafe" state severity beyond the hazard name, so kepler marks impact as present.
  10. present: Under a lunar standard, potentially hazardous conditions and unsafe water state severity beyond merely naming a storm.
  11. present: The meteor reading finds severity because the text says "potentially hazardous conditions" and calls rough water "unsafe".
  12. present: The nebula reading finds impact present because the storm is "expected to impact" the area with "potentially hazardous" and "unsafe" conditions.
  13. present: Phrases "potentially hazardous conditions" and "unsafe" convey severity and possible harm, which is the impact orbit rather than a bare hazard name.
  14. present: It calls the conditions potentially hazardous and unsafe, which pulsar reads as stated severity beyond the hazard name.
  15. present: A quasar check finds severity, since the text calls the surf conditions potentially hazardous and unsafe rather than only naming a storm.
  16. present: Potentially hazardous and unsafe conditions state severity beyond the storm name, so rigel codes impact present.
  17. present: The solar wording calls the surf potentially hazardous and unsafe, so the severity of harm is stated beyond merely naming a storm.
  18. present: The titan reading finds severity, because the storm is called potentially hazardous and conditions are described as unsafe.
  19. present: "Potentially hazardous conditions" and calling the water "unsafe" state severity and possible harm, which is the umbra of impact.
  20. present: Vega finds impact because the storm is expected to impact the area with potentially hazardous conditions that can be unsafe.
  21. present: Potentially hazardous conditions and unsafe water state seriousness beyond merely naming a storm, a waxing consequence for people near the surf.
  22. present: The words potentially hazardous conditions and unsafe convey severity for xenon beyond merely naming the storm.
  23. present: The zodiac reading finds severity in "potentially hazardous conditions" and "unsafe", which state possible harm beyond naming the storm.
  24. present: "Potentially hazardous conditions" and "unsafe" state severity beyond naming the storm, so aurora codes Impact present.
  25. present: Potentially hazardous conditions and calling the water unsafe state severity, which supplies the corona impact.